Secrets of Mini-Multinationals
February 6 2012 by William J. Holstein
- There is no substitute for previous experience in new markets. Build
management teams and boards with meaningful global experience.
- Maintain intense sensitivity to local markets by, for example,
promoting local nationals and making them responsible for more
- Resist the impulse to compete with larger rivals on their terms.
Instead of mimicking their bureaucracy, exploit your agility and flatt
Think a company needs to be big to play on the world stage? Think
again. Plenty of companies in the $10 million to $1 billion range are
emerging as full-fledged international players by finding ways to move
faster than their bigger competitors. Just ask Dawne S. Hickton, CEO of
RTI International Metals, a $431 million titanium products company based
in Pittsburgh, who recounts what happened when an explosion ripped
through BP’s offshore oil platform in the Gulf of Mexico, resulting in a
huge spill. The head of her energy unit in Texas called her directly
and she authorized the immediate dispatch of a team of engineers. “When
that crisis hit and everyone was watching CNN, we had 40 engineers on
the platform out there working very closely with BP and others to
develop an alternative solution,” Hickton says. “We weren’t this giant
company that has to get every “I” dotted in a contract. A lot of their
very large suppliers didn’t have the flexibility to stop everything they
were doing, get all the approvals in place and get moving.”
The moral of the story is that you don’t have to be a giant to go global—that,
in fact, smaller companies can use their size as an edge in overseas
markets. Although it’s generally known that small to mid-size companies
can be successful as exporters of their products, what has largely
escaped attention is that a subset of these companies are defying the
conventional wisdom that one must be a multi-billion-dollar-a-year
multinational to play in such tricky markets as China and India. These
“mini-multinationals” do more than just export their products to a
single customer or a single distributor offshore. They operate
factories, sales offices and laboratories in multiple countries on
multiple continents. (See “A Sampling of Mini-Multinationals”)
They do so by leveraging their ability to be more agile, more focused on
a core competency and more entrepreneurial than their larger peers.
Here are some of the global strategies they employ:
• Focus on serving a relatively narrow technological niche.
While mini-multinationals as a whole play across the technological
spectrum, each focuses on competing in a core area of expertise. On the
larger end of the size range, privately held Revstone group, for
example, supplies large automakers like GM, Ford, Toyota, Volkswagen and
Hyundai with castings, forgings, tools and precision machining.
GrafTech International, based near Cleveland, manufacturers in four
countries and sells its graphite electrodes to steel producers in 65.
In other sectors, U.S. mini-multinationals are very competitive in
sectors where they combine manufactured products with systems know-how.
For example, Aeration Industries International of Chaska, Minn., sells
water pollution control equipment in multiple countries, particularly
China. While it might be easy for a competitor to imitate Aeration’s
equipment, it’s much more difficult to develop the body of knowledge
about how to use the equipment in particular circumstances.
Some mid-sized American companies are also particularly strong in new
cutting-edge technologies such as genomics decoding (Illumina); lithium
ion batteries (A123 Systems); advanced surgical instruments (Intuitive
Surgical); and software and services for mobile broadband systems
(Tekelec). These competitors have helped create brand-new business
• Expand step-by-step, exploiting adjacencies and new geographies.
The mini-multinationals are adept at taking their core technologies and
rolling them out in adjacent product segments—without straying too
far—while at the same time gradually expanding to new countries. “Don’t
try to go into 40 countries simultaneously,” warns Ron de Lange, CEO of
Tekelec, a mobile broadband software and services company that has
established offices in 20 countries in less than a decade. “That will
“We do everything we can to
empower our people to make decisions and not wait for bureaucracies and
committees on top of committees to make decisions.” —George Hofmeister,
His company has survived competition from giants like Cisco Systems,
China’s Huawei and Sweden’s Ericsson by staying focused on the brains of
the mobile broadband systems management by national operators such as
Deutsche Telekom and France’s Orange. Its largest single market outside
North America is India, where the vast majority of mobile Internet
traffic touches Tekelec systems. One key to Tekelec’s geographic
expansion has been piggybacking on the market presence of a systems
operator. If Deutsche Tekekom operates in 20 countries, Tekelec can sell
its product in all those markets by building relationships with DT
Some mini-multinationals infiltrate new turf by following their
customers into new terrain. In fact, Revstone expanded largely because
its largest customers demanded it. Ford Motors and General Motors are
both opening new factories in countries such as India. Revstone also
supplies the top German, Japanese and Korean automakers, which are
extending their global reaches. “We try to follow and serve our
customers,” says the company’s founder and chairman, George Hofmeister,
who built the company from scratch through a series of acquisitions and
recently turned over the CEO spot to successor Kevin G. Cramton, a
former Ford Motors executive. Revstone now operates 71 factories in the
United States, Canada, Mexico, China, India, Costa Rica and the
Dominican Republic and is closing deals in Germany, Hungary, Saudi
Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. Some 25 percent of its revenue
comes from outside the United States.
• Concentrate on remaining agile and entrepreneurial.
“We are very nimble,” says Hofmeister. “We do everything we can to
empower our people to make decisions and not wait for bureaucracies and
committees on top of committees to make decisions.” At Revstone, he
notes, the parent company imposes standards of accounting, quality,
efficiency and financial reporting, but each factory remains its own
profit center. That’s very different from how a standard multinational
seeks to homogenize its disparate manufacturing operations.
“We never try to homogenize—I wouldn’t even know how to spell that
word,” says Hofmeister. “We want to retain the competitive advantage and
the entrepreneurial spirit in each one of the operations. It allows
people on the front lines doing the business to understand what their
costs are and to determine our success or failure.”
An entrepreneurial culture and the flexibility that comes with a lack
of bureaucracy also helps a mini-multinational adapt quickly to changes
in overseas markets like China, which is 12 time zones and 12,000 miles
away with a very different culture. Dan Durda, chairman and CEO of
Aeration Industries International in Chaska, Minn., is in the midst of
moving assembly of the water pollution control equipment and systems his
company produces to China because the Chinese government has imposed a
24 percent duty on imported environmental products. “A large company has
to go to a committee and put together a lot of graphs and charts,” says
Durda, who notes that reacting quickly is essential to success in
China. “But entrepreneurs say, ‘Let’s go and see if it works.’ In bigger
companies, everybody is watching their backsides. If you’re a [Fortune
500] CEO, you have about six vice presidents right behind you looking
for you to slip up.”
Durda also protects his intellectual property by sourcing different
pieces of equipment from different contract manufacturers. “I learned
the hard way in Taiwan” in the 1980s, he says. “You don’t put everything
in one place. You disperse it. One person makes one piece in Dalian and
another makes something in Ningpo. You scatter it around so no one
knows what you’re making.”
• Build management teams and boards that include
non-Americans or recent immigrants and executives with international
experience. Mini-multinationals by definition tend to have
flatter managerial hierarchies, enabling them to be more sensitive to
local market preferences and conditions than their larger, more
top-heavy competitors, which tend to impose more policies from
headquarters on their local operations. CEOs like Craig Shular, chairman
and CEO of Parma, Ohio-based GrafTech International take that strength a
step further by appointing local nationals to manage its non-U.S.
subsidiaries whenever possible.
“When we do put an expatriate into the field, we work hard to make
that a limited assignment, a couple of years, to groom and develop the
local talent and then move on,” says Shular, a veteran of Union Carbide
who spent half his career living abroad. “We have huge operations in
Mexico, Brazil, South Africa and Europe, but you’re going to find no
expats. Nationals have the local language and local business skills, and
they can engage with the business community better than any expat can.”
GrafTech gives stock options to its foreign managers as readily as it
does to its headquarters staff to increase retention and Shular also
promotes local nationals to top management jobs at headquarters. His two
key operating vice presidents, for example, are both South African.
To be sure, not every mid-sized U.S. company that seeks to establish a
global footprint makes it. Some simply fail to develop essential
“global skills,” says Oded Shenkar, Ohio State professor of global
business and a specialist in mid-sized companies. “They don’t have a
tradition of working in other countries,” he says. “They don’t have a
tradition of learning about other cultures and how to operate in those
cultures.” Others fail at expanding because they were dragged into
international markets before they were ready. Sometimes, says Shenkar,
their largest customers tell them, “Listen, we don’t want to deal with
50 different suppliers around the world. Either you internationalize or
we are going to do business with someone else.” Often, these wannabes
“get acquired because they cannot muster the skills and the resources
that they need to survive in the global environment,” he notes.
However, for those that are ready, willing and committed to success,
evidence suggests that there are ways for mini-multinationals to
compete—and possibly even beat—larger competitors in global markets.
Whether it be through intense focus on a core expertise or greater speed
and flexibility, smaller companies can find and leverage an edge that
enables them to operate better and smarter than the big guys do.
The bottom line? Companies do not have to be giants to operate successfully on multiple continents.
SIDEBAR: The Sales Dilemma: Agent or In-Country?
At the early stages of simply exporting products, companies tend to
find an established distributor of similar products with a multi-country
footprint or hire independent agents to market, sell and distribute
their products. Each of those approaches has positives and minuses. The
plus side is that an exporter can get started with no or very little
capital outlay. But an exporter can get lost in a big distributor’s
entire portfolio of products. And agents can create performance
problems—do they really have the incentive to maximize sales?
That’s why many companies find, over time, that they need to
establish a bigger presence in key markets. As they grow in size and
capability, the American exporter can make a local acquisition and/or
establish a local full-time employee base that may involve marketing,
distribution, sales, testing, assembly and ultimately manufacturing. It
is more expensive to take the next step of creating an in-country
presence but it allows the company to have much better control over the
product, it allows a much better understanding of the ultimate
customer’s needs and it allows better financial controls. Ultimately,
most CEOs argue that it is more profitable than simply exporting.
SIDEBAR QUESTION AND ANSWER
Tekelec: Nimble in a Niche
Tekelec was founded in California but is now based in the Raleigh
suburb of Morrisville, N.C. Some 60 percent of its $424 million in 2010
revenue came from outside North America and 40 percent of its 1,250
employees are based outside the United States. The company, whose CEO
Ron de Lange is a first-generation Dutch descendant, specializes in the
brains of mobile broadband systems around the world, meaning it sells
mostly software and services, not hardware. The company’s focus and
agility often allows it to outflank competitors of much greater
magnitude. In the Q&A to follow, de Lange shares his strategies for
competing globally against larger firms.
Who do you compete against?
Most everyone we compete with is a mega-multinational such as Cisco Systems, Huawei, Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent.
How can you beat those guys?
We have offices in 20 countries and use a direct sales model. We have
used local sales agents to introduce us to the key decision makers at
telecom companies such as British Telecom, Orange and Deutsche Telekom.
They may be operating in 20 to 30 markets. If we can get into their
headquarters, then we can leverage their broad, geographic reach. We use
other people we call fulfillment partners to actually service the
accounts. We train them. Then we base our own subject matter experts
around the world. This strategy has accelerated our ability to
globalize, and we can keep some of our costs variable, rather than
Why don’t the big guys simply crush you?
We stick to our core competencies and we are very careful not to go
outside them. We are specialists in a very niche part of the market,
what is called the control plane of an operator’s network. We are the
brains of an operator’s network, not the brawn. We connect all the
organs of the body like a spinal cord, including the databases that they
use to bill customers and protect privacy. We have a number of patents
for doing all that; and, as we get feedback from the market, we can
adjust our go-to-market strategies more quickly than the big guys can.
How did you learn how to create such a global company?
I had years of experience with Lucent and was based in Amsterdam and
London for a period of time. Most of my management team consists of
people who have done a tour of duty with the large multinationals.
They’ve worked for Nortel, Lucent, Ericsson and other telecom companies
as well as for software companies like Symantec. They’ve had the breadth
of experience and they know how to do large-scale global growth. For
example, we’ve done four acquisitions outside the United States in
Amsterdam; France; the Czech Republic and Montreal, Canada. My board of
directors also has two members who are non-U.S. and bringing that
perspective is important. We’ve had sales conferences in different
places in the world and we try to create a multicultural environment.
Why would executives from larger companies want to work for such a small outfit as yours?
Well, the Raleigh area has been named the best place to live in the
United States. A smaller company also gives people an opportunity to
move and grow. It’s amusing to see an engineer visiting Pakistan for the
first time and bringing home candy as if it were so exotic. When you
have 1,250 people, you get exposed to more and you can have a bigger
impact on the business than if you are at a multinational where you are
one person out of 100,000.
Company Name: A123 Systems, a123systems.com
CEO: David Veau
HQ: Waltham, Ma.
Annual Sales: $105 million
Business: Lithium ion batteries for customers like BMW, Daimler and General Motors.
Multinational Presence: 28 percent of sales outside U.S.
Global Strategy Strength: Started manufacturing in China and South Korea before U.S. to achieve scale, drive down costs.
Company Name: Aeration Industries International, aireo2.com
CEO: Dan Durda
HQ: Chaska, Minn.
Annual Sales: $10 million+ (privately held)
Business: Water pollution treatment systems.
Multinational Presence: 50 percent of sales outside U.S. Largest market outside the U.S. is China.
Global Strategy Strength: Located contract manufacturing in different cities in China to avoid piracy.
Company Name: Graftech International, graftech.com
CEO: Craig S. Shular
HQ: Parma, Ohio
Annual Sales: $1 billion
Business: Graphite electrodes for the steel industry and new materials for advanced electronics.
Multinational Presence: 80 percent of sales outside the United States; Sales in more than 65 countries. Operates 14 plants on four continents.
Global Strategy Strength: Emphasizes hiring local nationals to manage foreign subsidiaries. Gives them stock and promotes them to headquarters.
Company Name: Illumina, illumina.com
CEO: Jay Flatley
HQ: San Diego
Annual Sales: $1 billion
Business: Machines and equipment for decoding human DNA.
Multinational Presence: 40 percent of sales outside U.S. Manufactures in Singapore among other locations. One of its largest customers is Chinese.
Global Strategy Strength: Has largely prevented the emergence of non-U.S. competitors by rapidly rolling out its technology around world.
Company Name: Intuitive Surgical, intusurg.com
CEO: Gary S. Guthart
HQ: Sunnyvale, Ca.
Annual Sales: $1.4 billion
Business: Makers of the daVinci minimally invasive surgical system.
Multinational Presence: 25 percent of sales outside U.S. Offices in Switzerland and China, manufactures in Mexico.
Global Strategy Strength: It is engaged in a classic roll-out of its core technology into adjacent fields and new geographies.
Company Name: Revstone Systems, revstone.com
CEO: George Hofmeister (chairman)
HQ: Lexington, Ky. & Southfield, Mich.
Annual Sales: $1 billion+ (privatley held)
Business: Supplies parts for GM, Ford, Toyota, Volkswagen and Hyundai.
Multinational Presence: 25 percent of sales are non-U.S. Operates 71 factories around world.
Global Strategy Strength: It grows by acquisition and allows each factory to remain its own profit center.
Company Name: RTI International Metals, rtiintl.com
CEO: Dawne S. Hickton
HQ: Pittsburgh, PA
Annual Sales: $431 million
Business: Makes titanium products for aircraft and offshore oil rigs. Supplier to Boeing and Airbus, as well as BP.
Multinational Presence: 33 percent of sales outside U.S., including exports from U.S. Locations in Britain, France, Canada and China.
Global Strategy Strength: Emphasizes that all managers of business units may call CEO directly for speedy decision making.
Company Name: TEKELEC, tekelec.com
CEO: Ron de Lange
HQ: Morrisville, N.C.
Annual Sales: $424 million
Business: Mobile broadband software and services.
Multinational Presence: 60 percent of sales outside U.S. Secondlargest market after North America is India.
Global Strategy Strength: Maintains a tight focus on making the brains of mobile broadband systems, rather than the brawn.